We are now over halfway through the NFL season and all of the awards are still very much up for grabs. The MVP, Offensive Rookie of the Year, and Defensive Player of the Year markets each have at least four players shorter than 10-1 to win the award, while Offensive Player of the Year and Defensive Rookie of the Year are down to two players each shorter than 10-1.
During the 2024 season, we analyzed the previous winners of each award and where they stood halfway through the season in SIS’ Total Points ranking as well as a few other metrics. We found that a few of the awards, like the Rookies of the Year, are highly correlated with high Total Points values. However, Defensive Player of the Year is rooted in pedigree, as all of the previous winners were former All-Pros.
With this information in mind, let’s take a look at where we stand in the 2026 campaigns.
MVP
The MVP race has taken shape and has four quarterbacks all under 10-1. Joe Burrow is the current favorite at -105 and is having his best season as a Bengal. His Independent Quarterback Rating (IQR) is the best of his career and he is operating with the lowest sack rate (under 5%) and pressure rate (33%) he has ever faced.
Josh Allen (+380) is having the prototypical Josh Allen season, getting it done through the air and on the ground. This has not been his best season metrically and is down the leaderboard a bit with his Total Points and IQR ranking, but even that still makes him a top candidate.
Brock Purdy (+440) is tied for 5th in TD with 20 and leads the NFL in IQR on 20+ yard throws. He is executing the offense at a high level even with the multitude of injuries the 49ers are dealing with, but he’s not driving the bus on offense as much as the two guys ahead of him
Lastly, Trevor Lawrence (+600) is in the midst of his best season as a Jaguar. He’s tied for 3rd in passing touchdowns and is 2nd in adjusted net yards per attempt with 8.6.
The race for the one seed in each conference is something to keep an eye on, as the winner usually is on a team that is the 1st or 2nd seed in the playoffs. Metrically, Burrow has the clear edge and is priced so in the market.
Offensive Player of the Year
The top 3 leaders in Total Points among non-quarterbacks are Kenneth Walker III (46), Jahmyr Gibbs (41), and Jaxon Smith-Njigba (38). These guys are also the top three in the betting markets to win the award, with Gibbs the favorite at +105 followed by JSN at +145 and Walker at +1600.
Gibbs has already accumulated 1,000 rushing yards and 11 rushing touchdowns this season, both good for 1st in the NFL. His 11% Boom rate (runs that accumulate one EPA or more) and 32% first down rate also rank first among running backs, showing that he is getting things done with splash plays on a consistent basis. 384 yards through the air on 53 targets isn’t too shabby either, the 3rd-most among running backs. He is doing this behind a middling offensive line that has taken a step back the last couple years, as the Lions rank 13th in Pass Blocking and 14th in Run Blocking Total Points.
JSN won the 2025 Offensive Player of the Year and is putting up better numbers already in 2026. He has already matched his 2025 touchdown total with 10 and accumulated one more missed tackle (12). His 1,207 receiving yards leads the league by a wide margin and is on pace to surpass Calvin Johnson’s record of 1,964 in 2012.
Walker may only have the 4th-most rushing yards with 872 and a Boom Rate tied for 4th at 9%, but his value generation is off the charts. He is forcing broken and missed tackles at a 28% clip, the highest in the league. He is 2nd in yards per attempt with 5.5 and is tied for 3rd in yards after contact per attempt with 3.3. His recent groin injury held him out of the game against Atlanta, and his counterpart Emmett Johnson has burst onto the scene as a rookie.
This race usually comes down to which player can push towards a record on a team that is clearly in the Super Bowl hunt. Gibbs and JSN fit that bill, even if their teams aren’t exactly the NFC favorites. If both end up breaking the records they are chasing, JSN probably deserves it more because of how little help the rest of the Seahawks are providing on offense.
Defensive Player of the Year
Will Anderson Jr. is the favorite at +100, followed by Dallas Turner at +400, Jeffrey Simmons at +700, Fred Warner at +700. This award primarily has gone to a player who came into the season as an All-Pro in a prior season and on a defense that ranks in the top 10 in total defense.
The favorite, Will Anderson Jr., leads the league in sacks with 10.5 and is 2nd in pressures with 52. He is getting to the quarterback at a 5% higher rate than expected. Not only is he getting it done in pass rushes, but he leads the league in tackles for loss on run defense with 17.
Turner is the second favorite, as he is thriving in his third season in Coach Flores’ defense. Turner is T-4th in both sacks with 8 and pressures with 46, all while getting pressure at a 3% higher rate than expected. His run defense isn’t as stellar and doesn’t have the previous pedigree as some of the names on this list. He also might suffer from the perception that the scheme is driving his success.
Someone who does have the pedigree is Jeffrey Simmons, who has been nothing but a menace since getting to Chicago. His 6 sacks are tied for 2nd among defensive tackles, while his 5.2 tackles per game on run defense ranks 1st. Simmons is a force on a defense who will continue to make noise as a Super Bowl contender.
Fred Warner has been the do-it-all linebacker for the 49ers for quite some time and has only needed to stay healthy in order to be a true Defensive Player of the Year contender. He is tied for the league lead in forced fumbles with 5, 14th overall in run defense Total Points, and is 4th among linebackers in pass coverage Total Points. The question with him is if he can overcome the pass rushing standard that has seemed to be set by the voters, because he can do everything else at the best level in the league. He could also use some splash plays in the passing game, as he has just one assisted sack and no interceptions.
From a Total Points perspective, Anderson Jr. is 4th, Warner is 12th, Simmons is 16th, and Turner is 34th among non-secondary defensive players. (Secondary play results in a lot of swingy results that can lead to big Total Points value that isn’t as bankable over a larger sample.) Over the years, Total Points hasn’t been as correlative when projecting this award winner, but winners have usually hovered around the top 10 by this time.
Offensive Rookie of the Year
Nobody has been able to pull away in this race yet. Usually, the winner has been in the top 10 in Total Points by this point in the season, but the favorite Fernando Mendoza (+250) just had his first career start this past weekend. He was sacked 6 times by the vaunted Seahawks defense, but the Raiders weapons have shown they can produce when called on this season.
Jonah Coleman (+500), the second favorite, has carved out a solid role in the Broncos backfield and has seen an increase in touches each of the last 3 weeks. This has come due to injuries to J.K. Dobbins and R.J. Harvey, and Coleman has taken advantage. He still ranks only 12th among skill position rookies in Total Points with 7, but a bigger workload looms.
KC Concepcion (+550) and Denzel Boston (+900) are 9th and 3rd in Total Points among eligible players, respectively, and have each carved out nice roles in a surprisingly productive Browns offense. Each has more than 450 receiving yards while Boston has 3 touchdowns and Concepcion has only 1. Unfortunately, these two will eat into each other’s production playing the same position on the same team.
Two names to monitor are Chiefs RB Emmett Johnson (+900) and Saints WR Jordyn Tyson (+1500). Johnson is the rookie Total Points leader with 35, which is the 4th highest among all skill position players in the league! He has been taken under the wing by his counterpart, Walker, and learned how to shed tackles, ranking 2nd in broken and missed tackles per attempt at 29%. Tyson has now played in two games for the Saints and has already amassed 18 targets.
Usually, the quarterback can produce at a much faster rate. With middling production elsewhere, Mendoza might be able to gain ground quickly even though he stands at 21st in Total Points. But with only a half-season available to him, he needs to not just play but play well.
Defensive Rookie of the Year
This award is the one that rewards production the most, as players who win this award have been in the top 3 in Total Points among eligible non-secondary players by this time since 2017. The odds on favorite, Arvell Reese (-150), ranks 3rd with 22 Total Points. The second favorite, David Bailey (+390), sits at the top spot with 32 and is 2nd overall among all non-secondary defensive players.
Reese has taken a big step forward over the last few weeks against the Commanders and Eagles, posting 12+ tackles in each game and contributing to 3 sacks and a forced fumble against the Eagles. He has accumulated 4.5 sacks on 11 pressures as a pass rusher while adding in 9 TFL’s and 7 Total Points on run defense. He ranks 13th among linebackers in pass defense Total Points with 10.
Bailey has been more productive than Reese, posting 7.5 sacks on 34 pressures, which are tied for 7th and 11th among all players, respectively. He is getting pressure at a 4% higher clip than expected, which is good for 11th among all players. He is tied with the league high in forced fumbles with 5 and is tied for 8th in TFLs with 10. He has more run defense Total Points than Reese with 13.
Based on current production, Bailey has done more than Reese on all facets except for total tackles and pass coverage. He has certainly made more splash plays and has made a greater statistical impact. This feels like a situation where the odds are a bit out of whack with what’s happened on the field.



