We make 2 lists to analyze the question. And you'll probably be surprised where Derrick Henry ended up on one of those lists.
Where do Justin Herbert and Joe Burrow fit in on our respective lists?
Kevin Zeitler and Quenton Nelson each showed up near the top on one list, but not both. Check out how they and other offensive linemen fared.
There was close to a consensus on the excellence of Fred Warner, but our groups differed on Grant Delpit. See who joined them in rating among the best of the best.
The suspense here isn't over who's in the Top 3, but rather where players like T.J. Hockenson and Kyle Pitts slot in within our stats and rankings.
Tony Pollard made the Top 5 on one of our lists. Read to find out who else joined him and what other surprises were in store.
Sauce Gardner and Jalen Ramsey are among the best, but only one garnered the top spot on one of our lists.
Yes, ideally you want a blend of stats and scouts, but this makes for good discussion. The No. 1 on one list didn't even make the other!
Ja'Marr Chase landed at No. 3 on one list ... but did he even make the cut on another?
